Einstein's unsuccessful investigations
Albert Einstein conducted several unsuccessful investigations. These pertain to quantum mechanics, superconductivity, and his details on his own theory of relativity.
Special relativity
Transverse mass
In one of his three Annus mirabilis papers of 1905, on special relativity, Albert Einstein noted that, given a specific definition of the word "force" (a definition which he later agreed was not advantageous), and if we choose to maintain (by convention) Newton's second law of motion F = ma (mass times acceleration equals force), then one arrives at $\scriptstyle m/(1-v^{2}/c^{2})$ as the expression for the transverse mass of a fast moving particle. This differs from the accepted expression today, because, as noted in the footnotes to Einstein's paper added in the 1913 reprint, "it is more to the point to define force in such a way that the laws of energy and momentum assume the simplest form", as was done, for example, by Max Planck in 1906, who gave the now familiar expression $\scriptstyle m/{\sqrt {1-v^{2}/c^{2}}}$ for the transverse mass.
As historian Arthur I. Miller points out, this is equivalent to the transverse mass predictions of both Einstein and Hendrik Lorentz. Einstein had commented already in the 1905 paper that "With a different definition of force and acceleration, we should naturally obtain other expressions for the masses. This shows that in comparing different theories... we must proceed very cautiously."^{[1]}
Minkowski's work
Einstein did not immediately appreciate the value of Hermann Minkowski's four-dimensional formulation of special relativity, although within a few years he had adopted it within his theory of gravitation.^{[citation needed]}
General relativity and cosmology
Black holes
Einstein denied several times that black holes could form.^{[citation needed]} In 1939 he published a paper that argues that a star collapsing would spin faster and faster, spinning at the speed of light with infinite energy well before the point where it is about to collapse into a Schwarzchild singularity, or black hole.
The essential result of this investigation is a clear understanding as to why the "Schwarzschild singularities" do not exist in physical reality. Although the theory given here treats only clusters whose particles move along circular paths it does not seem to be subject to reasonable doubt that more general cases will have analogous results. The "Schwarzschild cannot be concentrated arbitrarily. And this is due to the fact that otherwise the constituting particles would reach the velocity of light.^{[2]}
Einstein's argument itself only shows that stable spinning objects have to spin faster and faster to stay stable before the point where they collapse. But it is well understood today (and was understood well by some even then) that collapse cannot happen through stationary states the way Einstein imagined. Nevertheless, the extent to which the models of black holes in classical general relativity correspond to physical reality remains unclear, and in particular the implications of the central singularity implicit in these models are still not understood.
Closely related to his rejection of black holes, Einstein believed that the exclusion of singularities might restrict the class of solutions of the field equations so as to force solutions compatible with quantum mechanics, but no such theory has ever been found.^{[citation needed]}
Cosmological constant
Einstein himself considered the introduction of the cosmological constant in his 1917 paper founding cosmology as a "blunder".^{[3]} The theory of general relativity predicted an expanding or contracting universe, but Einstein wanted a static universe which is an unchanging three-dimensional sphere, like the surface of a three-dimensional ball in four dimensions.
He wanted this for philosophical reasons, so as to incorporate Mach's principle in a reasonable way. He stabilised his solution by introducing a cosmological constant, and when the universe was shown to be expanding, he retracted the constant as a blunder. This is not really much of a blunder – the cosmological constant is necessary within general relativity as it is currently understood, and it is widely believed to have a nonzero value today.
Quantum mechanics
Heisenberg's work
Finding it too formal, Einstein believed that Werner Heisenberg's matrix mechanics was incorrect. He changed his mind when Erwin Schrödinger and others demonstrated that the formulation in terms of the Schrödinger equation, based on wave–particle duality was equivalent to Heisenberg's matrices.^{[citation needed]}
Einstein also tried to show that Heisenberg's uncertainty principle was not valid. By 1927 he had become convinced of its utility, but he always opposed it.^{[citation needed]}
EPR paradox
In the EPR paper, Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen argued that quantum mechanics cannot be a complete realistic and local representation of phenomena, given specific definitions of "realism", "locality", and "completeness". The modern consensus is that Einstein's concept of realism is too restrictive.^{[citation needed]}
Superconductivity
Einstein published (in 1922) a qualitative theory of superconductivity based on the vague idea of electrons shared in orbits. This paper predated modern quantum mechanics, and today is regarded as being incorrect. The current theory of low temperature superconductivity, BCS theory (by John Bardeen, Leon Cooper and John Robert Schrieffer) was only worked out in 1957, thirty years after the establishing of modern quantum mechanics. However, even today, superconductivity is not well understood, and alternative theories continue to be put forward, especially to account for high-temperature superconductors.^{[citation needed]}
Unified field theory
Einstein spent many years pursuing the unified field theory of physics, and published many papers on the subject spanning from 1918 up until his passing in April of 1955. Einstein was never able to prove the unified field theory. Theoretical physicists have not yet formulated a widely accepted, consistent theory that combines general relativity and quantum mechanics to form a theory of everything. Trying to combine the graviton with the strong and electroweak interactions leads to fundamental difficulties and the resulting theory is not renormalizable. The incompatibility of the two theories remains a key unsolved problems in physics.
References
- ^ Miller, Arthur I. (1981), Albert Einstein's special theory of relativity. Emergence (1905) and early interpretation (1905–1911), Reading: Addison–Wesley, pp. 325–331, ISBN 978-0-201-04679-3
- ^ Einstein, Albert (October 1939). "On a Stationary System With Spherical Symmetry Consisting of Many Gravitating Masses". Annals of Mathematics. 40 (4): 922–936. doi:10.2307/1968902. JSTOR 1968902.
- ^ Wright, Karen (30 September 2004). "The Master's Mistakes". Discover Magazine. Retrieved 15 October 2009.
- v
- t
- e
- Theory of relativity
- Mass–energy equivalence (E=mc^{2})
- Brownian motion
- Photoelectric effect
- Einstein coefficients
- Einstein solid
- Equivalence principle
- Einstein field equations
- Einstein radius
- Einstein relation (kinetic theory)
- Cosmological constant
- Bose–Einstein condensate
- Bose–Einstein statistics
- Bose–Einstein correlations
- Einstein–Cartan theory
- Einstein–Infeld–Hoffmann equations
- Einstein–de Haas effect
- EPR paradox
- Bohr–Einstein debates
- Teleparallelism
- Thought experiments
- Unsuccessful investigations
- Wave–particle duality
- Gravitational wave
- Tea leaf paradox
- Annus mirabilis papers (1905)
- "Investigations on the Theory of Brownian Movement" (1905)
- Relativity: The Special and the General Theory (1916)
- The Meaning of Relativity (1922)
- The World as I See It (1934)
- The Evolution of Physics (1938)
- "Why Socialism?" (1949)
- Russell–Einstein Manifesto (1955)
culture
- Die Grundlagen der Einsteinschen Relativitäts-Theorie (1922 documentary)
- The Einstein Theory of Relativity (1923 documentary)
- Relics: Einstein's Brain (1994 documentary)
- Insignificance (1985 film)
- Young Einstein (1988 film)
- Picasso at the Lapin Agile (1993 play)
- I.Q. (1994 film)
- Einstein's Gift (2003 play)
- Einstein and Eddington (2008 TV film)
- Genius (2017 series)
- Oppenheimer (2023 film)
Einstein
- Albert Einstein: Creator and Rebel
- Einstein and Religion
- Einstein for Beginners
- Einstein: His Life and Universe
- Einstein's Cosmos
- I Am Albert Einstein
- Introducing Relativity
- Subtle is the Lord
- Mileva Marić (first wife)
- Elsa Einstein (second wife; cousin)
- Lieserl Einstein (daughter)
- Hans Albert Einstein (son)
- Pauline Koch (mother)
- Hermann Einstein (father)
- Maja Einstein (sister)
- Eduard Einstein (son)
- Robert Einstein (cousin)
- Bernhard Caesar Einstein (grandson)
- Evelyn Einstein (granddaughter)
- Thomas Martin Einstein (great-grandson)
- Siegbert Einstein (distant cousin)
- Category