Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Site | Most Valuable Player |
1991 | Indiana^ | 2–0 | Wisconsin | Bill Armstrong Stadium • Bloomington, IN | |
1992 | Indiana (2) | 2–1 | Penn State | Bill Armstrong Stadium • Bloomington, IN | |
1993 | Penn State | 1–0 | Wisconsin | McClimon Stadium • Madison, WI | |
1994 | Indiana^ (3) | 3–1 | Penn State | Owens Stadium • Columbus, OH | |
1995 | Indiana (4) Wisconsin‡ | cancelled[note 1] | — | DeMartin Soccer Complex • East Lansing, MI | |
1996 | Indiana (5) | 4–0 | Michigan State | Jeffrey Field • University Park, PA | |
1997 | Indiana^ (6) | 1–0 | Ohio State | Bill Armstrong Stadium • Bloomington, IN | |
1998 | Indiana‡ (7) | 1–0* | Penn State | Lakeside Field • Evanston, IL | |
1999 | Indiana‡ (8) | 2–1* | Penn State | DeMartin Soccer Complex • East Lansing, MI | |
2000 | Ohio State | 3–2* | Penn State | Owens Stadium • Columbus, OH | |
2001 | Indiana^ (9) | 2–0 | Michigan State | McClimon Stadium • Madison, WI | |
2002 | Penn State (2) | 2–1 | Michigan | Jeffrey Field • University Park, PA | |
2003 | Indiana‡ (10) | 1–1† (4–1 pen.) | Penn State | Bill Armstrong Stadium • Bloomington, IN | |
2004 | Michigan State | 1–0 | Northwestern | U-M Soccer Stadium • Ann Arbor, MI | |
2005 | Penn State (3) | 1–0 | Indiana | Lakeside Field • Evanston, IL | |
2006 | Indiana (11) | 1–0 | Ohio State | Owens Stadium • Columbus, OH | |
2007 | Ohio State^ (2) | 0–0† (5–4 pen.) | Indiana | DeMartin Soccer Complex • East Lansing, MI | |
2008 | Michigan State (2) | 1–0 | Indiana | McClimon Stadium • Madison, WI | |
2009 | Ohio State (3) | 1–0 | Penn State | Bill Armstrong Stadium • Bloomington, IN | |
2010 | Michigan^ | 4–1 | Penn State | Jeffrey Field • University Park, PA | |
2011 | Northwestern | 2–1 | Penn State | U-M Soccer Stadium • Ann Arbor, MI | |
2012 | Michigan State (3) | 2–1* | Michigan | Lakeside Field • Evanston, IL | |
2013 | Indiana (12) | 1–0 | Michigan State | Crew Stadium • Columbus, OH | |
2014 | Maryland | 2–1 | Indiana | Ludwig Field • College Park, MD | |
2015 | Maryland (2) | 2–0 | Ohio State | Owens Stadium • Columbus, OH | |
2016 | Maryland (3) | 3–1 | Wisconsin | Grand Park • Westfield, IN | |
2017 | Wisconsin (2) | 0–0† (4–2 pen.) | Indiana | Grand Park • Westfield, IN | |
2018 | Indiana^ (13) | 3–0 | Michigan | Grand Park • Westfield, IN | |
2019 | Indiana (14) | 0–0† (4–3 pen.) | Michigan | Ludwig Field • College Park, MD | |
2020 | Indiana^ (15) | 1–1† (3–2 pen.) | Penn State | Bill Armstrong Stadium • Bloomington, IN | |
2021 | Penn State (4) | 3–0 | Indiana | Jeffrey Field • University Park, PA |
2022 | Rutgers (1) | 3–1 | Indiana | Yurcak Field • Piscataway, NJ |
2023 | Indiana (16) | 1–0 | Penn State | Bill Armstrong Stadium • Bloomington, IN | |